top of page

Governance by “It”

15 hours ago
4 min read

By Dennis A. Minott, PhD.

November 21, 2026



Readers, please forgive me for the bluntness that follows—and for an impatience I can no longer comfortably disguise. It is the impatience of a scientist-educator who has spent decades helping young Caribbean people meet exacting intellectual standards, only to watch public discussion too readily accept something less exacting when the responsibility is the governance of our country.


My concern is straightforward: we must stop mistaking titles, connections, celebrity, skin-complexion, and command rank for demonstrated fitness to undertake a particular public responsibility. I call that substitution governance by “It”.


I am, at heart, a scientist-educator—conditioned to observe, discern, and, ideally, categorise patterns accurately even amid the noise of apparent randomness. My life’s work makes this particular pattern difficult to ignore. When one has spent decades insisting that gifted young people submit their abilities to rigorous examination, one is hardly inclined to applaud the apparent exemption of their prospective leaders from comparable scrutiny.


For decades, my work—and burden—has been nurturing bright, often spectacularly gifted young minds across these Caribbean lands and beyond. Admissions committees at Oxford, Williams, Macalester, Columbia, UniAndes, Harvey Mudd, Cornell, UWI, Grinnell, Stanford, Harvard, the Rhodes Trust, and the United World Colleges can all attest to the calibre of talent this region produces when intellectual rigour is taken seriously.


I invoke those institutions not to suggest that foreign recognition confers worth upon Caribbean intelligence. It does not. I invoke them because the young people with whom I have worked have repeatedly had to demonstrate their preparation, discipline, and capacity before exacting evaluators. They could not simply announce an affiliation, display a title, or rely upon the warmth of public familiarity.


Why, then, should our examination of those entrusted with national responsibility be less searching?


That is the connection between my life’s work and my present disquiet. I find it difficult to reconcile the standards we demand of our young scholars with the slightness of some of the reasoning offered in Cabinet-level defence of consequential public appointments.


Permit me, therefore, to vent cautiously—but plainly—on a troubling pattern that I believe has become increasingly conspicuous in Jamaican public life: governance by “It”.


Rather than beginning with the demands of the responsibility and asking who possesses the relevant competence, we appear too willing to begin with a recognisable person, title, or affiliation and treat the question of suitability as already settled.


The label becomes the argument.


Just as troubling is the popular intellectual indolence that can greet these decisions: the willingness to applaud a familiar name, an imposing uniform, an impressive credential, or a reassuring connection without asking whether the appointee understands the machinery he or she has been handed to run.


By 'intellectual indolence', I do not mean an absence of intelligence. I mean the refusal to put intelligence to work when political loyalty, social familiarity, or admiration makes scrutiny uncomfortable.


These are the pre-eminent “Its” to which I refer:


Party, Fren an’ Company It

Sports Celebrity It

Non-Beenie-Man 2026 Musical Icon It

Attorney-at-Law It

Light Complexion (of Any Competence Level) It

‘Doctorate’ in Any God-Forsaken Thing It

Military General It

Admiral It

Commander It

Colonel It

Superintendent It

Brigadier It

------?----It

----??-----It

Man Let-off Cash it


Proven fitness and ability, integrity, and genuine leadership in civic situations????, next

DEEPLy mastered fiduciary and humanitarian duties of a Caribbean team to its population pre-, and post-disaster ?????????


The repetition is deliberate. General. Admiral. Commander. Colonel. Superintendent. Brigadier. I spell them out because the accumulation is part of the pattern I am asking Jamaicans to examine. To compress them into the decorous phrase “uniformed leadership” would conceal the very prominence I wish to question.


But let there be no convenient misunderstanding. Military or police service is not a disqualification for civilian responsibility. Neither is being a lawyer, a musician, an athlete, or the holder of a doctorate.


The question is whether the particular person’s preparation fits the particular responsibility. A rank tells us something about a career. It does not, by itself, answer every subsequent question about competence. Neither does a degree, a sporting triumph, a musical achievement, or a party connection.


What, precisely, has this person demonstrated that equips him or her to lead this institution, manage this portfolio, or resolve this problem?


That question should not be regarded as insolence. It is an elementary obligation of citizenship.



Nor should a doctorate end the inquiry. A doctorate in what? Relevant to which responsibility? Supported by what experience, judgment, and record of delivery? My deliberately irreverent phrase, “in Any God-Forsaken Thing”, is directed at the worship of the credential irrespective of its relevance—not at the legitimate pursuit of knowledge.


The same scrutiny must apply to the rest of the list. Sporting excellence deserves its recognition. Artistic achievement deserves its applause. Professional accomplishment deserves its respect. None automatically establishes the capacity to govern.


To proceed as though it does is foolhardiness. To refuse even to examine the assumption is intellectual indolence. And to defend a consequential appointment with little more than the appointee’s title is to expose the Cabinet-level slightness of the defence.


Leadership, certainly, requires more than specialised knowledge. Integrity, judgment, courage, the ability to listen, and the capacity to assemble and heed competent advice all matter. But these, too, must be demonstrated rather than inferred from celebrity, pedigree, stars, pips, crossed swords, or epaulettes.


The standard I am arguing for is neither exotic nor impossibly demanding: relevant expertise, proven fitness and ability, integrity, and genuine leadership—matched to the responsibilities of the office.


My objection is not that Jamaica lacks talent. My life’s work has furnished me with abundant reasons to reject that proposition. My objection is that we cannot credibly celebrate the rigorous cultivation of Caribbean talent while excusing superficiality in the selection of those entrusted with public power.


We must demand more of those who appoint. We must also demand more of ourselves when we applaud.


And what of the “It” that should govern the choice above all others: demonstrated fitness for the task?


That is the “It” we should insist upon.


Until Jamaica musters the civic courage to demand competence over cosmetics—and to challenge a patronage culture that mistakes pedigree, rank, and popularity for statecraft—we risk remaining a nation richly endowed with world-class talent, yet governed too often by the superficial.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
A-QuEST LOGO
bottom of page