top of page

COMMENTARY: Byron Blake | Critical assessment of nuclear energy in Jamaica’s future


JAMAICA GLEANER: Graphical representation of an under construction nuclear power plant. Amb Byron Blake writes: Positioned as an apt solution for a small island nation, SMRs are presented as a ‘burgeoning technology’” But, that burgeoning is all ‘on paper’, as it is still at the design stage.

Here is My Hard Question #1:


Q1: If a small modular nuclear reactor (SMR) in the Caribbean goes wrong, who can physically or by financial means stop it before it causes widespread harm in our relatively small archipelagic crescent of geographical space?

This question is hard because it forces us to confront the reality of nuclear incidents and accidents, which can be catastrophic and irreversible. Even if we or the owner can summarily replace the top managers of an SMR plant with more "experienced experts," it may not be enough or in time to avert a disaster. SMRs are a new and unproven technology, and there is no guarantee that they will be safe or that the new hires know anything appropriate to do since the technology would be absolutely novel to them. How do you fix something like a get-away hazardous process that you do not quite understand when, even at your quickest and brightest, you have no time to learn because "things" are so immediate?

In the event of a nuclear accident, the consequences could be devastating for the Caribbean region. The islands are densely populated and rely heavily on tourism, which would be severely disrupted by even a hint of a nuclear disaster. The region is also certainly vulnerable to earthquakes, hurricanes, and other natural disasters, which could make it difficult to contain a nuclear accident. The Jamaican and all Caribbean people deserve a serious and honest assessment of the risks and benefits of SMRs. They need to know that if something goes wrong, there may be no way to stop it.


Consider These Additional 5 Hard Questions:

Q2: How can we ensure that SMRs are safely designed, built, and operated in the Caribbean?

Q3: What are the long-term risks of nuclear waste disposal in the region?

Q4: What are the economic and social costs of nuclear accidents?

Q5: Are there better proven and practically risk-free green alternatives to SMRs for meeting the Caribbean's energy needs?

Q6: Can any Caribbean terrorist gang/insurgents or group of enemy combatants gain the capacity to hold citizens or any governing authority to ransom by occupying OR targeting an SMR from 300 Ukraine-like Kilometers ?

These are just six of the hard questions that need to be answered before any decision is made about whether to deploy SMRs in the Caribbean.

As I recall, Jamaica is still within the Caribbean where even a little 5.0 magnitude shaker near Hope Bay vibrated The Turks, Cuba, Florida and Hispaniola. Within exactly 3 minutes of 7:31 pm that Thursday, one of my friends in America was calling to know if I was OK. I hate to break it this way: My Friend understands geophysics. My Daughter is a Yale Fellow Geophysics Specialist and my Late Wife was an ODPEM director who understood these matters very well as she taught the stuff at university level for many years up to months before she died of cancer. As a Physicist who communicated with my tribe, I would be dishonest if I pretended ignorance of the true reason for my friend's call. Here it is:

The Enriquillo-Plantain Garden fault zone is a major fault system that extends through Haiti and the Dominican Republic into Jamaica. It is a strike-slip fault, where the motion is primarily horizontal, with the Caribbean plate moving eastward relative to the Gonâve microplate. This fault has been associated with significant earthquakes in the past, including the devastating 2010 Haiti earthquake which laid claim to 0.25 million human lives in minutes. Both Jamaica and Haiti are located in seismically active regions, and understanding the fault lines and tectonic activity in these areas is crucial for assessing and mitigating seismic risks to even the best-designed SMR, touted by our wealthiest citizens who know money movements but, respectfully, not the deadly movements of neighborhood tectonic plates. My learned friend in America does and called me immediately. Flow's cables remained unbroken---one more time.

12 views0 comments

Comments


_edited_edited.jpg
bottom of page